张昊,米阳,陈耀威,应宜辰,时帅,郑晓亮
ZHANG Hao,MI Yang,CHEN Yaowei,YING Yichen,SHI Shuai,ZHENG Xiaoliang

• 1:上海电力大学电气工程学院
• 2:安徽理工大学电气与信息工程学院

摘要(Abstract)：

针对传统单一博弈模型难以解决电力市场多主体利益冲突与源荷不确定性问题，提出一种配电网运营商-虚拟电厂-产消者联盟多主体分层决策框架。首先，构建基于双Stackelberg-Nash混合博弈的三层能量交易架构：上层决策以配电网运营商收益最大化为核心目标，中层博弈引导虚拟电厂实现效益优化，下层通过产消者联盟协同降低用电成本。其次，引入纳什谈判理论，将产消者间的合作博弈解耦为两阶段优化问题，形成兼顾个体理性与集体效率的混合博弈优化模型。然后，基于KKT条件与McCormick包络法，将模型转化为双层混合整数线性规划问题，并结合Kriging元模型优化算法实现高效求解。最后，仿真结果表明，所提策略在提升系统主体收益、降低用电成本依赖性及增强风险应对能力方面具有显著优势。
Traditional single-game models face challenges in resolving multi-agent interest conflicts and addressing source-load uncertainties in electricity markets. To overcome these limitations, this paper proposes a multi-agent hierarchical decision-making framework involving distribution system operators(DSOs), virtual power plants(VPPs), and prosumers coalitions. First, a three-level energy trading architecture based on a Stackelberg-Nash hybrid game is developed: The upper-level decision-making layer focuses on maximizing DSO's operational revenue, the middle-level game layer guides the VPPs to achieve economic efficiency optimization, and the lower-level cooperation layer enables prosumer coalitions to collaboratively reduce electricity consumption costs. By introducing Nash bargaining theory, the cooperative game among prosumers is decoupled into a two-stage optimization problem, thereby establishing a hybrid game optimization model that simultaneously considers individual rationality and collective efficiency. Through the KKT conditions and McCormick envelope methods, the model is transformed into a bilevel mixed-integer linear programming(MILP) problem, which is then efficiently solved using a Kriging metamodel optimization algorithm. Simulation results demonstrate that the proposed strategy exhibits significant advantages in enhancing the economic benefits of all participating entities, reducing dependence on electricity consumption costs, and strengthening the system's risk resilience capability.

关键词(KeyWords)： 配电网运营商;虚拟电厂;产消者联盟;混合博弈;三层优化
DSO;VPP;prosumer coalition;hybrid game;three-level optimization

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金(52477107);; 上海市自然科学基金(22ZR1425500)

作者(Author): 张昊,米阳,陈耀威,应宜辰,时帅,郑晓亮
ZHANG Hao,MI Yang,CHEN Yaowei,YING Yichen,SHI Shuai,ZHENG Xiaoliang

DOI: 10.19585/j.zjdl.202602006

参考文献(References)：

• [1]赵毅，王维庆，闫斯哲.考虑阶梯型碳交易的风光储联合系统分布鲁棒优化调度[J].电力系统保护与控制，2023,51(6):127-136.ZHAO Yi,WANG Weiqing,YAN Sizhe.Distributionally robust optimization scheduling of a joint wind-solarstorage system considering step-type carbon trading[J].Power System Protection and Control,2023,51(6):127-136.
• [2]李令宇，程浩忠，张衡，等.含高比例新能源电力系统的低碳电源规划方法[J].电测与仪表，2025,62(7):30-37.LI Lingyu,CHENG Haozhong,ZHANG Heng,et al.Low-carbon power planning method for power system with high proportion of renewable energy[J]. Electrical Measurement&Instrumentation,2025,62(7):30-37.
• [3]张爱军，刘会强，慕腾，等.计及经济-低碳时空匹配的高比例新能源电力系统扩展规划[J].智慧电力，2024,52(11):72-80.ZHANG Aijun,LIU Huiqiang,MU Teng,et al. Expansion planning for high proportion of renewable energy power system considering economy-low carbon spatiotemporal matching[J].Smart Power,2024,52(11):72-80.
• [4]张爱军，刘石川，慕腾，等.新能源发电富集地区输电系统规划方案的综合评价[J].智慧电力，2025,53(2):16-24.ZHANG Aijun,LIU Shichuan,MU Teng,et al.Comprehensive evaluation of transmission system planning schemes in renewable energy generation enrichment region[J].Smart Power,2025,53(2):16-24.
• [5]乔奕宁，肖飞，艾芊，等.虚拟电厂需求侧灵活性资源聚合参与调峰的优化调度策略[J/OL].电力自动化设备，2024:1-19.(2024-12-20). https：//link. cnki. net/doi/10.16081/j.epae.202412030.QIAO Yining,XIAO Fei,AI Qian,et al.Optimal dispatching strategy of demand-side flexible resource in virtual power plant for aggregately participating in peak shaving[J/OL].Electric Power Automation Equipment,2024:1-19.(2024-12-20). https：//link. cnki. net/doi/10.16081/j.epae.202412030.
• [6]王宣元，刘敦楠，刘蓁，等.泛在电力物联网下虚拟电厂运营机制及关键技术[J].电网技术，2019,43(9):3175-3183.WANG Xuanyuan,LIU Dunnan,LIU Zhen,et al.Operation mechanism and key technologies of virtual power plant under ubiquitous Internet of Things[J].Power System Technology,2019,43(9):3175-3183.
• [7]彭思佳，邢海军，成明洋.多重不确定环境下考虑阶梯型碳交易的虚拟电厂低碳经济调度[J].上海交通大学学报，2023,57(12):1571-1582.PENG Sijia,XING Haijun,CHENG Mingyang.Low carbon economic dispatch of virtual power plants considering ladder-type carbon trading in multiple uncertainties[J].Journal of Shanghai Jiao Tong University,2023,57(12):1571-1582.
• [8]汤军，高洪超，余涛，等.电力市场环境下超大城市虚拟电厂的建设理念与创新实践[J].电网技术，2025,49(1):103-112.TANG Jun,GAO Hongchao,YU Tao,et al.Construction concept and innovative practices of virtual power plants in megacities under electricity market environment[J].Power System Technology,2025,49(1):103-112.
• [9]黄宇翔，黄蔚亮，牛振勇，等.虚拟电厂市场机制与盈利模式及欧洲运行实例分析[J].电力系统自动化，2025,49(9):17-30.HUANG Yuxiang,HUANG Weiliang,NIU Zhenyong,et al.Market mechanisms and profit modes of virtual power plants and analysis of their operation cases in Europe[J].Automation of Electric Power Systems,2025,49(9):17-30.
• [10]朱月尧，祁佟，吴星辰，等.计及实时碳减排的产消群价格型需求响应机制[J].上海交通大学学报，2023,57(4):452-463.ZHU Yueyao,QI Tong,WU Xingchen,et al.Price-based demand response mechanism of prosumer groups considering real-time carbon emission reduction[J]. Journal of Shanghai Jiao Tong University,2023,57(4):452-463.
• [11]王鹏，喻译，赵艺涵，等.基于纳什谈判的光伏产消者与共享储能协同参与市场优化策略[J].电网技术，2025,49(2):642-652.WANG Peng,YU Yi,ZHAO Yihan,et al. Optimization strategy for collaborative market participation of photovoltaic prosumers and shared energy storage based on Nash bargaining[J].Power System Technology,2025,49(2):642-652.
• [12]李军祥，梁贤武，屈德强，等.基于区块链技术的光伏产消者集群定价博弈[J].电力系统保护与控制，2024,52(5):73-82.LI Junxiang,LIANG Xianwu,QU Deqiang,et al.A pricing game for a photovoltaic prosumer cluster based on blockchain technology[J]. Power System Protection and Control,2024,52(5):73-82.
• [13]王国英，王成福，牛远方，等.含产消者租赁共享储能的主动配电网协同优化决策[J].电力系统自动化，2025,49(1):105-116.WANG Guoying,WANG Chengfu,NIU Yuanfang,et al.Cooperative optimal decision-making for active distribution network with shared energy storage leased by prosumers[J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems,2025,49(1):105-116.
• [14]漆磊，高扬，艾芊.基于能量共享的虚拟电厂多产消者混合博弈策略[J].电力建设，2025,46(1):1-13.QI Lei,GAO Yang,AI Qian. Virtual power plant and multi-prosumer hybrid game strategy based on energy sharing[J]. Electric Power Construction,2025,46(1):1-13.
• [15]宋梦，经昕怡，蔡昀峰，等.基于产消者能量-备用联合共享的虚拟电厂优化运营方法[J].电力系统自动化，2024,48(18):3-13.SONG Meng,JING Xinyi,CAI Yunfeng,et al. Optimal operation method for virtual power plant based on joint sharing of energy and reserve of prosumers[J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems,2024,48(18):3-13.
• [16]李逸超，胥栋，徐刚，等.计及碳捕集和多能流的虚拟电厂多目标优化调度[J].浙江电力，2023,42(10):34-44.LI Yichao,XU Dong,XU Gang,et al.Multi-objective optimal scheduling of virtual power plant considering carbon capture and multi-energy flow[J]. Zhejiang Electric Power,2023,42(10):34-44.
• [17]葛成扬，林顺富，谭津，等.含多个产消者的虚拟电厂日前协调优化运行策略[J].电网技术，2025,49(6):2521-2532.GE Chengyang,LIN Shunfu,TAN Jin,et al.A day-ahead optimal coordination strategy for a VPP with multiple prosumers[J].Power System Technology,2025,49(6):2521-2532.
• [18]LIN W T,CHEN G,ZHOU X J. Distributed carbonaware energy trading of virtual power plant under denial of service attacks:a passivity-based neurodynamic approach[J].Energy,2022,257:124751.
• [19]JU L W,YIN Z,ZHOU Q Q,et al.Nearly-zero carbon optimal operation model and benefit allocation strategy for a novel virtual power plant using carbon capture,power-togas,and waste incineration power in rural areas[J]. Applied Energy,2022,310:118618.
• [20]YAN X Y,GAO C W,MENG J,et al.An analytical target cascading method-based two-step distributed optimization strategy for energy sharing in a virtual power plant[J].Renewable Energy,2024,222:119917.
• [21]LYU R,MA S S,YANG J L,et al.Construction method of virtual power plant based on optimized aggregation of prosumer resources[C]//2020 4th International Conference on HVDC(HVDC). November 6-9,2020,Xi’an,China.IEEE,2020:388-393.
• [22]CHEN Y,NIU Y G,QU C Z,et al. A pricing strategy based on bi-level stochastic optimization for virtual power plant trading in multi-market:Energy,ancillary services and carbon trading market[J].Electric Power Systems Research,2024,231:110371.
• [23]WANG J N,GUO C L,YU C S,et al. Virtual power plant containing electric vehicles scheduling strategies based on deep reinforcement learning[J]. Electric Power Systems Research,2022,205:107714.
• [24]YIN S R,AI Q,LI Z Y,et al.Energy management for aggregate prosumers in a virtual power plant:a robust Stackelberg game approach[J].International Journal of Electrical Power&Energy Systems,2020,117:105605.
• [25]郑瑛，黄辉，戚奇峰，等.基于点对点交易的智能楼宇电能优化调度[J].浙江电力，2024,43(11):123-132.ZHENG Ying,HUANG Hui,QI Qifeng,et al. Optimal scheduling of electrical energy in smart buildings based on peer-to-peer transactions[J]. Zhejiang Electric Power,2024,43(11):123-132.
• [26]AZIM M I,LANKESHWARA G,TUSHAR W,et al.Dynamic operating envelope-enabled P2P trading to maximize financial returns of prosumers[J].IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid,2023,15(2):1978-1990.
• [27]LI G G,LI Q Q,SONG W,et al.Incentivizing distributed energy trading among prosumers:a general Nash bargaining approach[J].International Journal of Electrical Power and Energy Systems,2021,131:107100.
• [28]JIANG A H,YUAN H H,LI D L.Energy management for a community-level integrated energy system with photovoltaic prosumers based on bargaining theory[J]. Energy,2021,225:120272.
• [29]SUN B,LI M Z,WANG F,et al.An incentive mechanism to promote residential renewable energy consumption in China’s electricity retail market:a two-level Stackelberg game approach[J].Energy,2023,269:126861.
• [30]SINGH A,SETHI B K,KUMAR A,et al.Three-level hierarchical management of active distribution system with multimicrogrid[J].IEEE Systems Journal,2022,17(1):605-616.
• [31]WANG H Y,ZHANG C H,LI K,et al. Distributed coordinative transaction of a community integrated energy system based on a tri-level game model[J].Applied Energy,2021,295:116972.
• [32]MENG Y,FAN S,SHEN Y,et al.Transmission and distribution network-constrained large-scale demand response based on locational customer directrix load for accommodating renewable energy[J].Applied Energy,2023,350:121681.
• [33]QIAO J P,MI Y,MA S Y,et al. Trilayer Stackelberg game scheduling of active distribution network based on microgrid group leasing shared energy storage[J].Applied Energy,2025,382:125157.
• [34]ESFAHANI M,ALIZADEH A,AMJADY N,et al. A distributed VPP-integrated co-optimization framework for energy scheduling,frequency regulation,and voltage support using data-driven distributionally robust optimization with Wasserstein metric[J]. Applied Energy,2024,361:122883.
• [35]ZHOU K L,PENG N,YIN H,et al.Urban virtual power plant operation optimization with incentive-based demand response[J].Energy,2023,282:128700.
• [36]RAHIMIYAN M,BARINGO L. Strategic bidding for a virtual power plant in the day-ahead and real-time markets:a price-taker robust optimization approach[J].IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,2016,31(4):2676-2687.
• [37]董雷，涂淑琴，李烨，等.基于元模型优化算法的主从博弈多虚拟电厂动态定价和能量管理[J].电网技术，2020,44(3):973-983.DONG Lei,TU Shuqin,LI Ye,et al.A Stackelberg game model for dynamic pricing and energy management of multiple virtual power plants using metamodel-based optimization method[J].Power System Technology,2020,44(3):973-983.