许高秀,邓晖,房乐,龚开,王旭,蒋传文
XU Gaoxiu,DENG Hui,FANG Le,GONG Kai,WANG Xu,JIANG Chuanwen

• 1:电力传输与功率变换控制教育部重点实验室(上海交通大学)
• 2:国网浙江省电力有限公司电力科学研究院
• 3:国网浙江省电力有限公司电力市场仿真实验室

摘要(Abstract)：

需求侧灵活性资源是未来支撑新型电力系统运行的重要手段之一，可以有效应对高比例可再生清洁能源并网带来的挑战，科学、合理、完善的辅助服务市场机制对推进需求侧灵活性资源的利用和发展具有重要意义。为此，对当前国内外典型辅助服务市场机制的相关研究与市场实践进行调研与综述。首先，分析梳理国内现有的需求侧灵活性资源参与电力辅助服务市场交易的机制，总结当前市场机制运营存在的若干问题；然后，介绍澳大利亚、美国、英国的相关市场机制，以及在需求侧灵活性资源利用方面进行的探索和实践；最后，对需求侧灵活性资源的利用以及未来我国电力辅助服务市场的建设提出相关建议。
As one of the essential means to support the operation of new power systems in the future,demand-side flexible resources can effectively deal with the challenges brought about by the integration of high-proportion renewables and clean energies. A scientific,rational,and perfect ancillary service market mechanism is significant in promoting the utilization and development of demand-side flexible resources. Therefore,this paper investigates and summarizes the current research and market practice of auxiliary service market mechanisms at home and abroad.Firstly,the existing domestic ancillary service market mechanisms for demand-side flexible resources participating in auxiliary service market trading are sorted out,and several problems existing in the operation of the current market mechanism are summarized. Then,the relevant market mechanisms of Australia,the United States,and the United Kingdom and their exploration and practice in flexible resource utilization on the demand side are introduced. Finally,future suggestions on the utilization of flexible resources on demand side and the construction of power ancillary service market in China are advanced.

关键词(KeyWords)： 辅助服务市场;需求侧灵活性资源;电力市场;市场机制
ancillary service market;demand-side flexible resources;electricity market;market mechanism

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国网浙江省电力有限公司科技项目（2006CB200303）

作者(Author): 许高秀,邓晖,房乐,龚开,王旭,蒋传文
XU Gaoxiu,DENG Hui,FANG Le,GONG Kai,WANG Xu,JIANG Chuanwen

DOI: 10.19585/j.zjdl.202209001

参考文献(References)：

• [1] SHARIFI R,FATHI S H,VAHIDINASAB V.A review on Demand-side tools in electricity market[J].Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,2017,72:565-572.
• [2] YU S Y,FANG F,LIU Y J,et al.Uncertainties of virtual power plant:Problems and countermeasures[J]. Applied Energy,2019,239:454-470.
• [3]吴界辰，艾欣，胡俊杰，等.需求侧资源灵活性刻画及其在日前优化调度中的应用[J].电工技术学报，2020,35(9):1973-1984.
• [4]周椿奇，向月，张新，等.V2G辅助服务调节潜力与经济性分析：以上海地区为例[J].电力自动化设备，2021,41(8):135-141.
• [5]姜婷玉，李亚平，江叶峰，等.温控负荷提供电力系统辅助服务的关键技术综述[J].电力系统自动化，2022,46(11):191-207.
• [6]高赐威，曹晓峻，闫华光，等.数据中心电能管理及参与需求侧资源调度的展望[J].电力系统自动化，2017,41(23):1-7.
• [7]张巍，缪辉.基于云储能租赁服务的风储参与能量-调频市场竞价策略研究[J].电网技术，2021,45(10):3840-3852.
• [8]曾君，胡家健，徐铭康，等.储能汇聚参与辅助调频服务的协同优化算法[J].控制理论与应用，2021,38(7):1051-1060.
• [9]张谦，邓小松，岳焕展，等.计及电池寿命损耗的电动汽车参与能量-调频市场协同优化策略[J].电工技术学报，2022,37(1):72-81.
• [10]崔杨，周飞杰，赵钰婷，等.考虑替代效应的电动汽车负荷参与调频辅助服务市场出清方式[J].电力自动化设备，2022,42(7):111-119.
• [11] OSóRIO G J,LOTFI M,GOUGH M,et al.Modeling an electric vehicle parking lot with solar rooftop participating in the reserve market and in ancillary services provision[J].Journal of Cleaner Production,2021,318:128503.
• [12]沈鑫，束洪春，方正云，等.考虑高能耗用户参与的调频服务跨链交易模型[J].电力系统自动化，2021,45(9):10-18.
• [13] YANG P,JI C,LI P,et al. Hierarchical multiple time scales cyber-physical modeling of demand-side resources in future electricity market[J]. International Journal of Electrical Power&Energy Systems,2021,133:107184.
• [14]文艺林，胡泽春，宁剑，等.基于分布鲁棒机会约束的充电运营商参与调峰市场投标策略[J].电力系统自动化，2022,46(7):23-32.
• [15]胡实，唐昊，吕凯，等.考虑广义需求侧资源的深度置信网络短期负荷预测方法[J/OL].控制理论与应用.（2021-10-19）[2022-03-17]. http：//kns. cnki. net/kcms/detail/44.1240.tp.20211018.1101.002.html.
• [16]宋大为，尹硕，何洋，等.基于虚拟电厂的多元小微主体参与现货市场的竞价策略[J].南方电网技术，2021,15(9):75-84.
• [17]任景，薛晨，马晓伟，等.源荷联动调峰辅助服务市场两阶段模型[J].电力系统自动化，2021,45(18):94-102.
• [18]吴洲洋，艾欣，胡俊杰，等.需求侧灵活性资源参与调频辅助服务的备用优化与实时调度[J].电力系统自动化，2021,45(6):148-157.
• [19]国家能源局.完善电力辅助服务补偿（市场）机制工作方案：国能发监管[2017]67号[A/OL].(2017-11-25)[2022-03-17].http：//zfxxgk.nea.gov.cn/auto92/201711/W020171122534679525254.docx.
• [20]史沛然，李彦宾，江长明，等.第三方独立主体参与华北电力调峰市场规则设计与实践[J].电力系统自动化，2021,45(5):168-174.
• [21]国家能源局浙江监管办.浙江省第三方独立主体参与电力辅助服务市场交易规则（试行）（征求意见稿）[A/OL].(2021-5-20)[2022-03-17].https：//shoudian.bjx.com.cn/html/20210520/1153660.shtml.
• [22]国家能源局华北监管局.第三方独立主体参与华北电力调峰辅助服务市场试点方案（征求意见稿）：华北监能市场[2020]208号[A/OL].(2019-11-15)[2022-03-17].http：//hbj. nea. gov. cn/adminContent/initViewContent.do?pk=000000006e69cbf9016e6e4b59700059.
• [23]国家能源局山东监管办.山东电力辅助服务市场运营规则（试行）（2021年修订版）（征求意见稿）[A/OL].(2021-09-03)[2022-03-17].http：//www.cnea.gov.cn/tzgg/content_6873.
• [24]王勇，游大宁，房光华，等.山东电力现货市场机制设计与试运行分析[J].中国电力，2020,53(9):38-46.
• [25]国家能源局华东监管局.上海电力调峰辅助服务市场运营规则（试行）：华东监能市场[2020]41号[A/OL].(2020-04-22)[2022-03-17]. http：//hdj. nea. gov. cn/load.loadPage. d? newsid=1482854.589&page=detail_index.xml&siteCode=hddjwucm&urlChannelId=1001274&urlMenuId=1001274.
• [26]国家能源局江苏监管办.江苏电力辅助服务（调峰）市场启停交易补充规则（征求意见稿）[A/OL].(2019-09-18)[2022-03-17]. http：//jsb. nea. gov. cn/news/2019-9/2019918104817.htm.
• [27]国家能源局江苏监管办.江苏电力市场用户可调负荷参与辅助服务市场交易规则（试行）[A/OL].(2020-11-10)[2022-03-17]. http：//jsb. nea. gov. cn/news/2020-11/20201110100742.htm.
• [28]国家能源局江苏监管办.江苏电力辅助服务（调频）市场交易规则（试行）[A/OL].(2020-07-03)[2022-03-17].http：//jsb.nea.gov.cn/news/2020-7/202073154200.htm.
• [29]国家能源局甘肃监管办.甘肃省电力辅助服务市场运营暂行规则的通知：甘监能市场[2021]72号[A/OL].(2021-05-06)[2022-03-17].http：//gsb.nea.gov.cn/view.asp?id=5023&typeid=0.
• [30]黄永皓，尚金成，康重庆，等.电力辅助服务交易市场的运作机制及模型[J].电力系统自动化，2003,27(2):33-36.
• [31] DIMITRIADIS C N, TSIMOPOULOS E G,GEORGIADIS M C.Strategic bidding of an energy storage agent in a joint energy and reserve market under stochastic generation[J].Energy,2022,242:123026.
• [32] WANG J,WANG X,WU Y.Operating reserve model in the power market[J].IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,2005,20(1):223-229.
• [33]胡宏，陈新仪，王利峰，等.面向新型电力系统的华东电网运行备用体系构建方法[J].上海交通大学学报，2021,55(12):1640-1649.
• [34] GHAHARY K,ABDOLLAHI A,RASHIDINEJAD M,et al.optimal reserve market clearing considering uncertain demand response using information gap decision theory[J]. International Journal of Electrical Power&Energy Systems,2018,101:213-222.
• [35]李嘉媚，艾芊，殷爽睿，等.虚拟电厂参与调峰调频服务的市场机制与国外经验借鉴[J].中国电机工程学报，2022,42(1):37-56.
• [36]史普鑫，史沛然，王佩雯，等.华北区域电力调峰辅助服务市场分析与运行评估[J].电力系统自动化，2021,45(20):175-184.
• [37] STRINGER N,BRUCE A,MACGILL I,et al.Consumer-led transition:australia's world-leading distributed energy resource integration efforts[J]. IEEE Power and Energy Magazine,2020,18(6):20-36.
• [38] AEMO. Virtual power plant demonstrations knowledge sharing report#2[Z/OL]. AEMO.(2020-07-22)[2022-04-01]. https：//aemo. com. au/-/media/files/electricity/der/2020/vpp-knowledge-sharing-stage-2.pdf.
• [39] AEMO.NEM virtual power plant(VPP)demonstrations program final design[Z/OL].AEMO.(2021-01-21)[2022-04-01]. https：//aemo. com. au/-/media/files/electricity/der/2021/nem-vpp-demonstrations_final-design.pdf?la=en.
• [40] AEMO.VPP demonstrations FCAS specification[Z/OL].AEMO.(2019-09-24)[2022-04-01].https：//aemo.com.au/-/media/files/electricity/nem/der/2019/vpp-demonstrations/vpp-demonstrations-fcas-specification.pdf?la=en.
• [41] FERC. Order No. 2222[Z/OL]. FERC.(2020-09-17)[2022-04-01]. https：//www. ferc. gov/media/ferc-orderno-2222-fact-sheet.
• [42] PJM.Order 2222-design discussion[Z/OL].PJM.(2021-10-27)[2022-04-01]. http：//www. pjm. com/-/media/committees-groups/subcommittees/dirs/2021/20211028/-item-03-order-2222-design-discussion.ashx.
• [43] PJM. PJM Manual 13:Emergency operations[Z/OL].PJM.(2022-03-23)[2022-04-01].https：//www.pjm.com/directory/manuals/m13/index. html#Sections/22%0Reserve%0Requirements.html.
• [44] PJM.2021 Demand response activity report[Z/OL].PJM.(2022-03-10)[2022-04-01].http：//www.pjm.com/-/media/markets-ops/dsr/2021-demand-response-activity-report.ashx.
• [45] FERNáNDEZ-MU?OZ D, PéREZ-DíAZ J I,GUISáNDEZ I,et al.Fast frequency control ancillary services:An international review[J].Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,2020,120:109662.
• [46] BORNE O,KORTE K,PEREZ Y,et al.Barriers to entry in frequency-regulation services markets:Review of the status quo and options for improvements[J]. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,2018,81:605-614.
• [47] ENTSO-E.Survey on ancillary services procurement,balancing market design 2020[Z/OL].ENTSO-E.(2021-05-25)[2022-04-03]. https：//www. entsoe. eu/publications/market-reports/.
• [48]朱继忠，叶秋子，邹金，等.英国电力辅助服务市场短期运行备用服务机制及启示[J].电力系统自动化，2018,42(17):1-8.
• [49]王玲玲，刘恋，张锞，等.电力系统灵活调节服务与市场机制研究综述[J].电网技术，2022,46(2):442-452
• [50]王蓓蓓，丛小涵，高正平，等.高比例新能源接入下电网灵活性爬坡能力市场化获取机制现状分析及思考[J].电网技术，2019,43(8):2691-2702.
• [51] MUHSSIN M T,CIPCIGAN L M,SAMI S S,et al.Potential of demand side response aggregation for the stabilization of the grids frequency[J]. Applied Energy,2018,220:643-656.
• [52] NIZAMI M S H,HOSSAIN M J,MAHMUD K. A nested transactive energy market model to trade demandside flexibility of residential consumers[J].IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid,2020,12(1):479-490.
• [53]李振坤，魏砚军，张智泉，等.有源配电网黑启动恢复供电辅助服务市场机制研究[J/OL].中国电机工程学报、（2021-10-19）[2022-04-03].http：//kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/11.2107.TM.20220118.1526.024.html.
• [54]陈启鑫，房曦晨，郭鸿业，等.电力现货市场建设进展与关键问题[J].电力系统自动化，2021,45(6):3-15.
• [55]肖云鹏，张兰，张轩，等.包含独立储能的现货电能量与调频辅助服务市场出清协调机制[J].中国电机工程学报，2020,40（增刊1）:167-180.
• [56]杨超，孙谊媊，王勇，等.国外典型调频辅助服务市场综述与启示[J].电力需求侧管理，2021,23(5):96-100.
• [57]包铭磊，丁一，邵常政，等.北欧电力市场评述及对我国的经验借鉴[J].中国电机工程学报，2017,37(17):4881-4892.
• [58]杨萌，张粒子，吕建虎，等.面向灵活性的电能量与辅助服务日前市场联合出清模型[J].中国电力，2020,53(8):182-192.
• [59] AEMO.Guide to ancillary services in the national electricity market[Z/OL]. AEMO.(2021-03-11)[2022-04-03].https：//aemo.com.au/-/media/files/electricity/nem/security_and_reliability/ancillary_services/guide-to-ancillaryservices-in-the-national-electricity-market.pdf.
• [60]浙江省发展改革委.浙江电力现货市场基本规则（征求意见稿）[A/OL].(2021-05-11)[2022-04-03].https：//fzggw.zj.gov.cn/art/2022/5/11/art_1599567_58934107.html.
• [61] DING T,WU Z,LV J,et al.Robust co-optimization to energy and ancillary service joint dispatch considering wind power uncertainties in real-time electricity markets[J].IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy,2016,7(4):1547-1557.
• [62] WANG J,ZHONG H,TANG W,et al.Optimal bidding strategy for microgrids in joint energy and ancillary service markets considering flexible ramping products[J].Applied Energy,2017,205:294-303.